Autonomy and the future of construction

The construction industry faces acute labour shortages, compounded by an aging workforce and rising demand. Autonomous and semi-autonomous machines offer a solution, transferring operator skill to technology. From enhancing safety and productivity to reducing rework, autonomy is reshaping job sites and enabling contractors to do more with fewer resources. Adam Khaw, Head of Autonomy, Danfoss Power Solutions, explains further.
The construction industry is consistently ranked among the sectors facing the highest labour shortages in the EU. According to the latest EURES report on labour shortages and surpluses, almost half of the occupations classified as being in shortage belong to the construction sector[i]. This labour shortage is due to a combination of factors, including an aging workforce, declining interest in trade professions, and the impact of Brexit on the availability of skilled workers from other European countries.
In the UK, the number of people employed in construction has declined by 10.8% since the pandemic, with an aging workforce exacerbating the problem. The construction sector has traditionally relied on a younger workforce, but declining birth rates and an older population mean there are fewer people entering the field to replace retiring workers. The Construction Industry Training Board estimates that an additional 251,500 workers are needed by 2028 to meet demand[ii].
Impending retirement of an older workforce means not only the loss of headcount, but also the loss of experience on the job site. The outcome is fewer and less experienced workers operating machinery, which could result in errors or even accidents, leading to rework and decreased productivity.
Autonomy is one solution to the lack of a skilled workforce as it moves the skill and experience an operator would typically have onto the machine. It is ideal in any off-highway sector that wants to increase safety, boost productivity, and enable greater precision. Let’s take a look at what is meant by autonomy in off-highway machines, and how it delivers benefits.
What is autonomy?
Many discussions around autonomy focus on self-driving vehicles. The reality is more nuanced than that, and there are important distinctions between autonomy in on- and off-highway vehicles. In passenger cars and trucks, the goal is to automate the vehicle. In off-highway machines, the goal is to automate the tasks the vehicle performs. The more tasks that are automated, the more autonomous the vehicle appears.
There are five levels of autonomy in off-highway machinery:
- Level 1: The driver controls most functions. Specific functions, such as steering, can be taken over by the machine upon the operator’s direction.
- Level 2: In certain circumstances, the machine can steer, accelerate, and brake. The operator is still directing and monitoring the action of the vehicle. This lightens the load for the operator, but they are very much engaged in the driving.
- Level 3: More complex actions are controlled and executed by the machine. In the right conditions, a machine can manage most driving aspects, including monitoring the environment. This allows the operator to control implements or other functions on the machine and take their eyes away from driving for short periods of time.
- Level 4: The machine can operate without human input or oversight, and multiple autonomous machines can work together on one site. However, supervision is required for edge cases. This is known as supervised autonomy.
- Level 5: The machine can operate without human input or oversight and can be controlled off-site. This is known as unsupervised autonomy.
When people think of autonomy, many think of driverless or even cab-less machines. While autonomous machines do exist today, they are often expensive and complicated. Few have penetrated the market. In 15 or 20 years, this might change. For now, the state of the art in off-highway is semi-autonomous functionality that increases the ease of use, safety, productivity, and precision of machines — in other words, Level 3 autonomy. These Level 3 machines can enhance productivity and safety on the job site from day one, even with a new operator at the controls.
Autonomy’s place in construction
While other off-highway sectors have a relatively advanced autonomy offering — agriculture being the foremost example — construction could see rapid development as new workers enter the industry. As previously mentioned, autonomous and semi-autonomous functionality improves safety, productivity, and precision, regardless of operator experience. In construction, this will lead to reduced rework and faster job completion.
Hyper-repetitive tasks are ideal candidates for automation. In construction, rollers and compactors are good examples. Soil compaction and asphalt rolling require highly skilled operators. If these tasks are not done properly, costly rework or accelerated road deterioration could result. By using autonomous functionality, these machines can compact soil or roll asphalt with proper overlaps and accuracy regardless of the operator. Additionally, an operator in a tandem roller with a limited field of view can be more aware of their surroundings.
Development efforts focused on obstacle detection and avoidance are particularly relevant in construction because large machines tend to have large blind spots. Accidents still occur because a driver didn’t see someone standing or working near the machine. Damage to nearby structures is also common. Collisions can be prevented by adding obstacle detection functionality to machines.
Path recording and following is another example of semi-autonomous operation relevant to construction. Such functionality is ideal for pipeline and power line work as well as other applications in which a machine needs to follow a long stretch of road or ground. This functionality enables an operator to drive a path, recording speed, waypoints, and tasks the machine does. A less experienced operator can then manage the machine as it follows the recorded path.
Blind spot detection has already proven successful in construction, as have semi-autonomous functions that enable inexperienced operators to rely on the machine. Many original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) in the construction industry have introduced advanced operator-assist features that ensure consistent, repeatable work. Auto-grade and auto-dig in excavators and boom kick-out and bucket positioning in wheel loaders are examples of functions we already see on job sites. Automation of such precision tasks that would otherwise require skill gained through years of experience is an ideal area for further development.
Autonomy in construction is ultimately about finding the right use cases. For example, solar farm construction would be ideal as the sites require numerous post placements at precise intervals. On megaprojects, haulers could be automated if they operate only within the confines of the site. This would mimic quarrying or mining operations, where rock haulers transport loads from excavators to a rock crusher or conveyor system. In fact, two haulers and one excavator could be operated simultaneously by one operator. The operator would record paths in each dump truck then oversee the trucks while operating the excavator.
Overcoming the challenges of automation
Autonomy has the potential to unlock significant advantages in the construction industry, making the choice between machines with and without autonomous functionality an easy one for contractors. For OEMs, however, automating machines is not always easy. The process presents new challenges, with considerations for software and hardware. Autonomy requires perception sensors such as lidar and radar, global positioning, high-power processors, and other technologies that may be new to design engineers. These technologies are not plug-and-play, and the sensors are not one-size-fits-all. Each application and environment has unique needs that demand different solutions, and there’s a significant amount of engineering work required to integrate these devices and services into a system.
Another challenge is knowing exactly what and how to automate. Single-use machinery that performs repetitive tasks, such as soil compactors, are relatively simple and straightforward to automate. But many types of construction machines are multifunctional. Skid steer loaders and excavators, for example, can perform many different operations. This means there’s many more tasks that can be automated. In addition, construction machinery often operates in complex, ever-changing job sites rather than a single, static environment, which makes autonomous operation more challenging.
Autonomy offers a lot of potential and exciting engineering possibilities. But just because it can be done, doesn’t necessarily mean it should be done. OEMs need to identify the problem they want to solve as early in the design process as possible — preferably in the ideation phase. This requires bringing together the product teams, systems teams, software teams, and autonomy experts before any lines of code are written.
Larger OEMs typically have established in-house teams focused on solving such engineering challenges. With the construction machinery market dominated by several large OEMs, small to mid-sized OEMs are at risk of falling behind.
Today, however, many suppliers and systems integrators offer solutions for automating machines. The Danfoss autonomy team, for example, offers products and services that support the full machine development cycle, including software, hardware, and engineering services. By building upon a foundation of field-tested solutions, smaller OEMs can take steps to remain competitive in a rapidly evolving industry, positioning themselves for the future of autonomous machinery.
Autonomy as a solution for workforce challenges
The benefits of autonomous and semi-autonomous machines for both OEMs and the wider construction industry are significant. While development requires close collaboration and strategic planning, autonomy can increase safety, boost productivity, and enable greater precision.
As such, autonomy can provide a solution for the lack of skilled labor in construction, and deliver results quickly. While workforce development takes time and cannot solve the labor shortage alone, autonomous technology offers a way forward, allowing contractors to achieve even more with limited resources.
[i] https://www.ela.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2024-05/EURES-Shortages_Report-V8.pdf
[ii] https://www.citb.co.uk/about-citb/news-events-and-blogs/over-250-000-extra-construction-workers-required-by-2028-to-meet-demand/
